NachtLaw, P.C. - Nacht & Roumel, P.C.
Protect Your Rights.
Call Today 888-312-7173

NachtLaw Challenges Internet Anonymity


NachtLaw, by Nicholas Roumel, represents Dr. Fazlul Sarkar, a prominent cancer researcher who was subject to a vicious smear campaign, by anonymous commenters on an anonymously hosted web site. With false and defamatory statements, including document forgery, these anonymous posters not only cost the researcher a promising new job offer, but caused him to lose his tenure with his present University position. On behalf of the researcher, NachtLaw sued "John and Jane Doe(s)" and subpoenaed the website to learn the identity of these posters.

Under the still-developing law in this area, it is difficult to learn the identity of anonymous commenters. While the trial judge blocked most of the subpoena, the judge granted NachtLaw an important victory by ordering some of the information to be released. Both NachtLaw and the attorneys for the website filed "cross-appeals," and the case is now pending at the Michigan Court of Appeals. A decision is expected soon: the case has been fully briefed and oral argument took place on October 4.

While anonymous posters have First Amendment protection, NachtLaw challenges whether they should be granted greater protection than commenters who post under their true names. This case is being closely watched by the scientific research community, and has elicited "friend of court" briefs filed by Google and Twitter, among others, on behalf of the website.

This case has also garnered international media attention, and was recently covered by the London-based "Economist".

For more information concerning this post, readers may contact author Nicholas Roumel.  

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
Email Us For A Response

Don’t Hesitate. Let Our Firm Help You Protect Your Rights.

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

We have developed a particular way we handle consultations at NachtLaw. Based on years of experience advising thousands of clients about their rights, we have settled on a method that allows our attorneys to provide the best advice possible in a setting that ensures confidentiality and promotes an atmosphere of trust.

Ann Arbor, MI
101 North Main Street Suite 555
Ann Arbor, MI 48104

Phone: 888-312-7173
Ann Arbor Law Office Map

Traverse City, MI
415 Cass Street Suite 2C
Traverse City, MI 49684

Phone: 888-312-7173
Traverse City Law Office Map

Toledo, OH
One Seagate Suite 685
Toledo, OH 43604

Phone: 888-312-7173
Toledo Law Office Map

Birmingham, MI
401 South Old Woodward Avenue Suite 460
Birmingham, MI 48009

Phone: 888-312-7173
Birmingham Law Office Map